Sarkaal hore oo Israa'iil ah ayaa sheegay in dagaalka Gaza la xalin lahaa muddo ka hor
Sarkaal sare oo hore u ahaa sarkaal ciidan oo Israa'iil ah ayaa sheegay in heshiis lagu soo celin lahaa dhammaan qofkii la qabtay muddo ka hor bishii October 2025, balse wuxuu sheegay in dagaalku uu ahaa mid aan loo baahnayn inuu socdo muddo dheer.
Fursad la waayay iyo xaqiiqada heshiiska
Sarkaal sare oo hore u ahaa sarkaal ciidan oo Israa'iil ah, Nitzan Alon, ayaa sheegay in heshiis lagu soo celin lahaa dhammaan qofkii la qabtay muddo ka hor bishii October 2025, balse wuxuu sheegay in dagaalku uu ahaa mid aan loo baahnayn inuu socdo muddo dheer. Alon wuxuu yiri: 'Waxaan u arkaa inaanu awoodnay inaan gaarno xilligan hore, haddii aanu ahayn sanad ka hor, iyadoo aan waxyeello weyn ku yeelan doonin xaqiijinta xisaabta dagaalka.'
Waxaa la gaaray heshiis bishii October 2025, kaas oo ahaa mid la gaaray xaalad degdeg ah, kaas oo lagu soo celinayay 20 qof oo Israa'iil ah oo la qabtay iyo 2,000 qof oo Falastiiniyiin ah oo xabsiyo ku jiray. Alon wuxuu sheegay in heshiiskan uu ahaa mid 'strategic achievement' ah, balse wuxuu sheegay in la awoodi lahaa in la gaaro xilligan hore, iyadoo aan waxyeello weyn ku yeelan doonin xaqiijinta xisaabta dagaalka.
Dadka kale oo ka hadlaya xaaladda
Alan Pinkas, wakiil hore oo Israa'iil ah, wuxuu sheegay in Netanyahu uu xakamaynayo dhamaadka dagaalka. Pinkas wuxuu yiri: 'Heshiis ayaa la awoodi karaa haddii ay dhacday haddii ay dhacday bishii October 2023, balse waxaa loo baahan yahay in la soo celinayo qofkii la qabtay muddo ka yar laba sano.'
Wasiirka Qaranka Qatar, Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman bin Jassim Al Thani, wuxuu sheegay in Israa'iil ay diideen inay ka hadlaan fariinta Hamas ee ah inay soo celinayaan dhammaan qofkii la qabtay iyadoo la gaaray heshiis degdeg ah. Wuxuu sheegay in Doha ay soo diray fariin ah inay u baahan yihiin fursad degdeg ah si ay u soo saaraan dadka rayidka ah, balse Israa'iil ay diideen inay ka hadlaan fariintaas.
Major General Nitzan Alon stated that a deal to return all Israeli captives could have been achieved much earlier than October 2025. Speaking at a Washington Institute event, the former negotiator argued the war was prolonged unnecessarily without major strategic implications.
Missed Opportunities for Early Ceasefire
Major General Nitzan Alon, who served as the army's point person for hostage negotiations, told a panel that a deal could have been secured maybe a year earlier. He emphasized that this earlier resolution would not have compromised other strategic goals of the war. Alon noted that the conflict lasted too long, stating, 'We missed it, actually. The war was too long.'
Former Israeli diplomat Alan Pinkas echoed these sentiments, telling Al Jazeera that Netanyahu had stalled the end of the war. Pinkas highlighted that a deal was possible very soon after the Hamas attack in October 2023. He described the delay as tragic, noting it took almost two years before the hostages were returned.
Diplomatic Rejections and Regional Warnings
Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman bin Jassim Al Thani revealed that Israeli officials rejected the idea of a Hamas proposal to release all captives in exchange for a limited ceasefire soon after the attacks. Doha reached out to Israeli officials on day one, stating that Hamas leaders were asking for a window of ceasefire to get civilians out, but the Israelis were not interested to engage in the idea.
The timeline of the conflict saw Hamas and Israel carry out a prisoner exchange deal in October 2025 under a ceasefire agreement. This deal resulted in the release of nearly 2,000 Palestinians imprisoned in Israeli jails and 20 Israeli captives held in the Gaza Strip. Alon referred to this October 2025 ceasefire as a strategic achievement that has since curbed Hamas's military power.
Ilaha iyo xuquuqda sawirka
Sawir: Al Jazeera English Xigasho
